Catastrophic AR Failure

We have a guest post by a reader named Josh. He shares with us his story about a catastrophic AR kaboom he had this year. It’s interesting to read how it all played out. But I also wish to add a datapoint of my own. Earlier this year, our local SWAT team had a Kaboom with factory ammo (Fiocchi) that resulted in the officer being temporarily disabled and his rifle destroyed. Upon inspection of his rifle and ammo, it was determined that the factory ammunition being used WAS NOT properly sized for the round. Thus leading to the rounds being able to be setback in the the cases. As for WHY this officer’s rifle kaboomed specifically that was never determined. Setback? Wrong powder? Powder leakage? Sympathetic detonation? All possible. Fiocchi replaced the officer’s rifle at their cost.—Marky, editor.

 

Earlier this year I had a catastrophic failure with a custom built AR-15 I assembled myself. Sorry it’s a bit long winded but I wanted to share this story as completely and honestly as possible in case it benefited any other shooters. The pictures will likely scare the crap out of even seasoned AR shooters.

The Event:

On 29 July 2016 I took two of my ARs to my local range to zero optics and break in a new upper i had just built. I brought several mags  of Tula .223 and two mags of Walmart brand Perfect .223 that had been loaded for several months and sitting in my safe. I ran all of the Tula through my 16” M&P-15 confirming zero and running drills. I then moved on to the magazine with Perfecta and shot about 25 rounds through the M&P-15 and decided to put that gun away.

Rifle Before the Kaboom

Rifle Before the Kaboom

I then put up a fresh target and prepared my new 10.5” upper on SBR lower with the intention of breaking in the barrel and zeroing my vortex red dot. I loaded the same magazine i was previously using with only 3-5 rounds of Perfecta left in it and chambered the first round. First shot fired with no issues and i saw that the round was left of POA. I reset the trigger and fired again and KABOOM – catastrophic failure. The upper receiver was cracked open and the mag was shattered everywhere. The bolt was stuck forward and wouldn’t budge. After my initial shock and mandatory body check I noted that i had a small gash and powder burns on my support arm.

My first observations after the event were the following:

– the second round left a clean hole in the target, although it was about 6” to the right of POA
– an undamaged and almost perfect looking 55gr projectile was sitting on the bench beside me, no case or powder were observed.
– a complete .223 round was also on the bench beside me, although the case was heavily crushed and deformed.
– the bolt catch on my SBR lower had sheared off
– the vortex optic and mount had been blown off and both were damaged
– the upper receiver was destroyed, and the bolt was also clearly destroyed.
the pmag was obliterated and pieces were everywhere.

The range employees at Elite Shooting Sports (Manassas VA) were friendly and helpful, but couldn’t clear the weapon on the line, so they took the rifle and we went back to the armorers bench to work on it. Getting the bolt out of the barrel extension pretty much took an act of god, as the bolt lugs didn’t want to come out of the barrel extension and eventually only came out with a lot of blunt force. The brass casing from the round that exploded was stuck in the chamber and could not be coaxed out. The case head separated at the neck and you could see the perfecta stamp, the .223 stamp and also the compression from the ejector which must have hit with considerable force. The lower receiver assembly (except the bolt catch) and Geissele rail were undamaged, but the upper receiver, bolt, carrier, charging handle and barrel extension were destroyed and the vortex sparc and its mount were damaged. At this point i took most of the pictures you see here.

The after-action:

I saved all the pieces and took some photos. After talking to my people the two obvious questions were “did you put .300 BLK through the barrel?” and “did you check the headspace?”. The answers were “No” and “No”. The possibility that the headspace was out of spec cannot be ruled out at this point. However, i was using a BCG and barrel from Rev Arms out of Danville VA and I have more faith in their QC than I do for Perfecta ammo, as they make quality guns (not budget) and parts for competition and their reputation while relatively new, is good. I had also previously used the same BCG in a different Rev Arms factory upper with no issues, and since the first round did fire successfully i think a headspace issue is much less likely than an ammo issue. (Note: i have since rebuilt my 10.5” upper with Rev Arms barrel and it is both in spec, and shoots great).

After doing some searching online i found the following article on soldiersystems.net about a duty rifle in the northeastern states that had a catastrophic failure, and the pictures mirrored my own remarkably close, the damage to the bolt, extractor, carrier, upper receiver, and right down to the damage to the separated case head all looked identical to what happened to my rifle. Open the PDF for all the pictures.
(http://soldiersystems.net/2014/06/12/report-catastropic-rifle-failure/)

I contacted the author of the article and he was happy to chat. His research ultimately pointed to a bad round causing the failure in that rifle, and he told me that the only way to replicate that kind of pressure in a .223/5.56 chamber was if two 55gr projectiles were loaded into a single case somehow. He said anything bigger than 55 gr wouldn’t fit, but if two 55 gr projectiles somehow made their way into a single case, it could cause that kind of pressure in the chamber and result in the catastrophic failure seen in his pictures. Don’t ask me how two bullets can end up in the same case, I’m just relaying the story.

Case Pic 3

Case Pic 3

At this point my honest impression was that I had horrible luck and a bad round was the cause of my rifle exploding in my face. So with no real expectations of any action on their part, i contacted the customer service office at TulaUSA (Perfecta is made by Fiocchi in Italy, but is imported by Tula so FiocchiUSA has nothing to do with it strangely) and left a message. I was contacted a few days later by the customer service representative who was very friendly and apologetic that i had a bad experience. He simply asked that i send any pictures i had and an explanation of what happened to his email address and promised to investigate. At that point i was surprised by how apparently willing he was to lean towards accepting responsibility for my rifle exploding.

The Final result:

About two weeks went by and Adam contacted me again apologizing for the delay, but that he had a death in the family that kept him out of the office. He finished by simply telling me to send him the cost of replacing my rifle, and they would take care of it. That was it. I thanked him,  gave consolations for his family loss and told him i would tally the cost to replace my rifle. I simply tallied the exact cost of the parts that were destroyed and passed him that total, $556 along with links to the exact parts for sale online for integrity. I really appreciated the level of customer service and care i received, i was legitimately shocked to be honest since i was not expecting a large company to react that way. I suppose that in cases like this the potential for litigious customers to cost the company a lot of money is high, so they would rather take care of people immediately for relatively small sums. Either way i clearly got lucky in more ways than one. I received a check in the mail from TulaUSA for $556 a few days later.

Rifle after after new upper installed / replaced.

Rifle after after new upper installed / replaced.

My key takeaways from this are:

– To avoid the cheapest ammo (i won’t shoot Perfecta .223 again, however i will still shoot Fiocchi pistol ammo and Tula 7.62×39, and my friend shoots ALOT of Perfecta 9mm),
– To always confirm headspace with custom rifle builds. Its a shame that my new upper exploded, but in the end I’m glad i didn’t get hurt.

Final Note:

I ended up replacing the broken parts at the Dulles Gun show the same weekend that my rifle exploded. Rev Arms was kind enough to give me a discount on a replacement barrel and I just bought the other parts out of pocket because i was impatient. After assembling another new 10.5” upper and checking the chamber specs, i took it to the range and put about 10 rounds through it. The first few rounds I had to shoot from behind the gun, with my support hand on the buttstock and the rail on a rest. I was too scared to be anywhere near it when it fired, I was legitimately shook from the experience. So after firing a few rounds slowly, with only a single round in the magazine, and ensuring the gun was in battery and chambering rounds properly i got more comfortable and fired a few more rounds holding it properly. I had to get back on the horse right away. Oh yeah, Vortex sent me a brand new Gen 2 Sparc and new mount for free no questions asked of course.

 

 

Josh S.
Virginia, USA

Marky Mark

Marky Mark

Writer at John1911.com
Writer for john1911.com. Co-Host of the John1911 Podcast. Video content provider for John1911-TV.

Areas of focus: Defense and National Security, Modern Light Weapons, Analysis of the Geo-political / Military Relationship in the Context of Strategic Goals.
Marky Mark

Latest posts by Marky Mark (see all)

  • Steve S.

    That would REALLY give Gersh Kuntzman a case of teh PTSD….

    Glad the guy is alright and Perfecta took care of him.

    • Steve S.

      PS Do you guys know what muzzle device is on that AR?

      • joshua shaw

        its a Ferfrans muzzle brake with a Concussion Reduction Device (CRD) fitted over it. It works as advertised and they also have good customer service.

      • Josh commenting is the owner of the AR and the author of the post.

        Marky

    • joshua shaw

      thanks, it was legitimately difficult to get back behind the gun after that….super annoying. Also, TulaUSA took care of me, as far as i know Perfecta/Fiocchi was not held accountable in any way.

    • Major pucker factor.

      Marky

  • Chris Bergen

    Wow… I am wholly impressed with the degree of the different manufacturers taking care of this. Not what I would have expected.. A recent difficulty with a mismanufactured 80% lower with no resolve left me concerned about any future orders or difficulties…

  • Gary Tompkins

    Thanks for sharing the information and the pictures. Glad you weren’t severely injured and everything turned out ok.

    • It’s a minor miracle he wasn’t seriously hurt. The SWAT guy hurt in the incident I mention was next to the KB. Not shooting it.

      Marky

  • Mikial

    Very glad the shooter was not seriously injured and that the story had a more or less happy ending with the ammo company taking responsibility. To be honest, my personal experience with manufacturers has been very positive. Some years ago my now ex-wife up blew her Kel Tec P32 with a squib round. (Yes, she has been replaced and I traded up for a younger wife who knew enough to recognize something was wrong when she had a squib round in a PPX recently.)

    But back to the story, the round in question was indeed a squib and I contacted the ammo manufacturer. They had me send them the gun and the remainder of the box of ammo. They had the gun completely rebuilt at their expense and they reimbursed me the MSRP for the box of ammo. What more could i ask for?

    I have had one other more-or-less serious ammo failure with my XD, and the factory was wonderful in helping me rectify the issue. I know some people have negative experience with gun and ammo manufacturers, and I do not doubt their stories, but my own personal experience has been very positive in terms of responsible customer service.

    Guns are machines and ammo is a component of those machines. Machine fail occasionally. In those cases we simply deal with it or find another passion . . . which for me is simply not an option.

    • If you shoot enough, you’ll see factory ammo have issues. It’s math.

      Marky

  • CJ Moore

    Thank you for sharing this.

  • joshua shaw

    Another reason to always wear eye pro!

  • Daniel, God is my judge

    Glad you are OK Josh. You must be living right from the looks of that mess. I picked up some Perfecta 308 that was being clearanced a while back and ratholed it, I really hope this stuff was loaded right.

    • joshua shaw

      id recomend that you inspect and weigh every single round personally before shooting it, but my issue was with the .223 so maybe im just paranoid.

      • Mikial

        Josh, it’s not paranoid if there is actually a reason to be concerned. Thanks for the story, glad it turned out okay.

      • The reality is, depending on who you are, inspecting every example of a high volume round like 223 is probably not going to happen. But I see your point.

        Marky

  • Jerry Hlinsky

    Same thing happened to my custom built AR last year. Federal Premium didn’t do squat because there was no proof if was the ammo. I contacted the individual parts companies and they all took care of me except Fail Zero.

    https://m.reddit.com/r/ar15/comments/3pbh0b/catastrophic_ar15_failure/

  • Anthony Simonaitis

    So, just a thought… 2 bullets in the same round… a double strike during the bullet seating operation or the interrupted that allows one at a time to enter the press operation failed… so one put in and another pressed on top or two in the tube and the press drove the die to the set point pushing both bullets into the neck with the first being stuffed into the case…

    • That seems to be a prevailing theory on one KB I am aware of. Because the presence of a second unexplained bullet afterwards.

      Marky